Key Takeaways:

  1. The Moon’s origin remains a mystery, despite the Giant Impact Hypothesis suggesting it formed from debris after a collision with Theia.
  2. Recent simulations propose a faster Moon formation scenario, occurring within hours of the collision, challenging previous beliefs.
  3. High-resolution simulations reveal previously overlooked details, providing new insights into the Moon’s orbit and composition.
  4. Despite advances, simulations still can’t fully explain isotopic similarities between Earth and the Moon.
  5. Further analysis of lunar rocks and upcoming Artemis missions are crucial in unraveling the Moon’s formation and its implications for Earth’s history.
New simulations show the Moon forming within a few hours of the Earth-Theia collision outlined in the Giant Impact Hypothesis.
NASA’s Ames Research Center

The Moon has been a steadfast companion to Earth throughout its history. However, Earth’s relationship with the Moon has not always been as it is now.

Around 4.5 billion years in the past, during the formation of the solar system, there was no Moon orbiting Earth. At that time, a large celestial body roughly the size of Mars, known as Theia, collided with the young Earth. According to the commonly accepted theory called the Giant Impact Hypothesis, this collision caused debris to scatter around Earth, eventually coalescing to form the Moon.

Yet, this theory encounters certain challenges, particularly regarding the composition of lunar rocks. When samples were brought back from the Moon by Apollo astronauts, scientists discovered that the isotopic signatures of these rocks closely resembled those of Earth’s mantle. This similarity suggests that much of the Moon’s material originated from Earth.

The conventional Giant Impact Hypothesis proposes that most of the debris forming the Moon came from Theia. However, alternative explanations have struggled to account for the Moon’s current orbit.

Recent simulations conducted by scientists from Durham University’s Institute for Computational Cosmology propose a modified scenario. These simulations suggest that the Moon formed shortly after the collision with Theia, possibly within a few hours, which is significantly faster than previously believed.

Lead author Jacob Kegerreis remarked, “This opens up a whole new range of possible starting places for the Moon’s evolution.” Their findings were published in the Astrophysical Journal Letters.

The research team ran approximately 400 simulations of the Theia-Earth collision using smoothed particle hydrodynamics, a method that models particle behavior under both gravity and pressure. Unlike previous simulations, which used hundreds of thousands to millions of particles, these new simulations employed up to a hundred million particles, providing unprecedented detail.

The high-resolution simulations revealed behaviors previously overlooked in lower-resolution models. Kegerreis noted, “Standard resolutions can give you misleading answers.” Furthermore, the simulations produced a Moon with characteristics such as a wide orbit and a partially solid interior, offering potential explanations for the Moon’s tilted orbit and thin crust.

Despite these advancements, the simulations still cannot fully explain the isotopic similarities between Earth and the Moon. Even with 60 percent of the Moon’s material originating from Earth, there remains a discrepancy in isotopic composition.

Robin Canup, from the SwRI Space Science and Engineering Division, explained, “Even a clump with 60 percent protoEarth material, with the remainder from Theia, would still be expected to produce a much larger Earth-Moon isotopic difference than what we see.”

While the simulations suggest that material from both Earth and Theia may not have thoroughly mixed during the Moon’s formation, Canup considers this unlikely. She stated, “For any portion of the Moon that forms intact, there is no opportunity for mixing between the protolunar and post-impact Earth material to remove such compositional differences.”

To unravel the specifics of the Moon’s formation, further analysis of lunar rocks, particularly from unexplored regions and beneath the surface, is necessary. By combining data from these missions with simulations, researchers hope to unravel the mystery of how the Moon formed around Earth billions of years ago.

Understanding the Moon’s origins not only sheds light on Earth’s history but also provides insights into the evolution of other celestial bodies affected by similar collisions. As Vincent Eke, a researcher at Durham University, noted, “The more we learn about how the Moon came to be, the more we discover about the evolution of our own Earth.”

5 1 vote
Article Rating
Notify of

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments