Advanced civilizations may face stagnation or collapse due to an inability to sustain growth in innovation and energy demand.
The Fermi Paradox, questioning the absence of observable extraterrestrial life despite the vastness of the universe, might find an answer in this disturbing hypothesis.
The researchers propose that civilizations reaching a crisis point may either collapse or redirect their focus to homeostasis, limiting their ability to expand across the cosmos.
Close-to-collapse civilizations could be detectable by dissipating unsustainable levels of energy, raising the possibility that initial contact with extraterrestrial life might involve civilizations in crisis.
A potential solution to avoid collapse is a “homeostatic awakening,” where civilizations prioritize societal well-being, sustainable development, and harmony with the environment.
For decades, the perplexing question of why aliens have not visited Earth, as far as we know, has fueled scientific inquiry. In a recent study published in the Royal Society Open Science, astrobiologists Michael Wong and Stuart Bartlett propose a disturbing hypothesis that attempts to shed light on this cosmic mystery. Their argument revolves around the idea that advanced civilizations, upon reaching a critical point in their development, may be destined for stagnation or collapse.
The researchers argue that as space-faring civilizations expand and advance technologically, they encounter a crisis where innovation struggles to keep pace with the escalating demand for energy. This critical juncture leads to a choice between collapse or a shift towards equilibrium, forsaking the pursuit of unbounded growth. Their hypothesis aims to reconcile the Fermi Paradox, named after physicist Enrico Fermi, which highlights the contradiction between the vastness of the universe and the absence of observable extraterrestrial life.
Wong and Bartlett draw on studies of the “superlinear” growth of cities, indicating that as populations and energy consumption exponentially increase, crises or singularities emerge, potentially culminating in civilization-ending collapses. The researchers postulate that when a planetary civilization resembles a globally connected city, it faces an “asymptotic burnout,” where the time scale of innovation becomes dwarfed by the singularity-interval time scale.
In their proposal, civilizations on the brink of collapse would be conspicuous to humanity due to their unsustainable energy dissipation. The researchers suggest that many initial detections of extraterrestrial life might involve civilizations in crisis, portraying intelligence without wisdom.
To avert collapse, civilizations could undergo a “homeostatic awakening,” redirecting their focus towards societal well-being, sustainable development, and harmony with the environment. While space exploration might not be abandoned entirely, the scale would likely be limited, reducing the likelihood of contact with Earth.
The researchers point to instances of humanity’s “mini-awakenings” that addressed global crises, emphasizing the need for such shifts on a larger scale. However, they stress that their proposal is a hypothesis, designed to provoke discussion and future exploration rather than providing conclusive answers.
This hypothesis joins a plethora of other theories attempting to unravel the cosmic silence, including practical challenges of interstellar travel, the possibility of secret alien visits, and the idea that signals sent across the vast universe might take hundreds of thousands of years to reach their destination. The quest for understanding why extraterrestrial civilizations have not made direct contact with Earth continues, fueled by scientific curiosity and a desire to comprehend the mysteries of the cosmos.